Broker Watch

Broker watch: Macquarie caught amid market selloff, CBA miss and CSL poised for upside

Fri 13 May 22, 2:56pm (AEDT)
Macquarie and Westpac buildings
Source: iStock

Key Points

  • Macquarie selling might have been exacerbated by the market selloff
  • Brokers are all Neutral or Sell rated on CBA shares post Q3 earnings
  • Brokers were unphased by delays for CSL's Vifor Pharma acquisition

Every week, Market Index takes a look at noteworthy broker updates from the past week, for ASX 200 companies.

Macquarie caught in market selloff

A seemingly positive FY22 result from Macquarie Group (ASX: MQG) was seemingly lost amid the broader market selloff. The company's stock is down -10% since last Thursday, the day before the full year results.

Brokers (as reported by FN Arena) responded mostly positively to Macquarie's results, with a consensus price target of $202.50.

Credit Suisse was the only broker with an Underperform rating, flagging Macquarie as a major benefactor of low interest rates, which is all about to change.

2022-05-13 14 16 22-Window
CBA 12-month price chart

CBA weaker-than-expected Q3

 CBA (ASX: CBA) shares whipsawed between early losses of -1.2% and afternoon gains of 1.4% on Thursday following a rather soft third quarter update.

Cash profits fell -2% to $2.4bn and there was no specific mention of net interest margins besides a brief "NIM compression" comment.

Post earnings notes were either Neutral or Sell rated with a consensus price target of $92.08.

The main criticisms for CBA and its traditionally premium valuation to the other big four banks was:

  • System growth will moderate

  • No longer benefit from cheap funding from the Reserve Bank

  • Continuing mortgage competition will limit upside

2022-05-13 14 16 51-Window
CBA 12-month price chart

CSL emerges from the dust

CSL (ASX: CSL) is one of few ASX 200 companies unphased by the May selloff.

CSL is trying to break out of its 3-month trading range and pushing the 200-day moving average, which it hasn't traded above since last December.

On Thursday, CSL flagged that the regulatory approval process for its Vifor Pharma acquisition will take "a few more months."

The two CSL notes on Friday from Citi and Morgan Stanley didn't see this as an issue and retained Buy ratings. Consensus price targets sit at $319.00.

The general view is that all-important plasma collections are poised to return to pre-covid levels. The finalisation of the Vifor deal could be a potential catalyst for further upside, according to Morgan Stanley.

2022-05-13 14 17 30-Window
CSL 12-month price chart

Xero: Solid growth, wrong market

The market was far from forgiving when Xero (ASX: XRO) dipped back into loss making territory in FY22 after two consecutive years of growing profits. Xero shares finished Thursday -11.5% lower ($76.90) at a near 2-year low.

Also troubling investors was the fact that expenses were growing at pace with revenue. Cost factors including full-time employees, marketing and product design expenses all rose at least 30% year-on-year.

We've seen a massive deflation in the valuation of fast growing, notably loss making companies that had a massive run up last year.

Broker notes from Citi and Morgan Stanley retain outsized price targets (upside of more than 50%).

Macquarie seem to be the only broker with a down-to-earth price target of $80.00. Analysts described Xero's subscriber growth as 'weak' and downgraded its long-term subscription growth outlook.

2022-05-13 14 18 11-Window
Xero 12-month price chart


Written By

Kerry Sun

Content Strategist

Kerry holds a Bachelor of Commerce from Monash University. He is an avid swing trader, focused on technical set ups and breakouts. Outside of writing and trading, Kerry is a big UFC fan, loves poker and training Muay Thai. Connect via LinkedIn or email.

Get the latest news and insights direct to your inbox

Subscribe free