Why Lynas, Iluka Resources and rare earth stocks are soaring on Friday
The US government has created a powerful precedent for the broader ex-China rare earth industry. Here's what happened.
Source: Shutterstock
Mentioned
KEY POINTS
- The US Department of Defence invested US$400 million in MP Materials and guaranteed a minimum NdPr price of US$110/kg for ten years.
- MP Materials' stock surged 50% on the news, with the Pentagon securing approximately 15% ownership and agreeing to buy 100% of output from the company's magnet facility starting in 2028.
- The pricing guarantee signals the US government's willingness to pay significant premiums for supply chain security, creating a powerful precedent for the broader ex-China rare earths industry.
- Other rare earth producers like Lynas may struggle to capture similar premiums due to existing long-term contracts that lock in market pricing, limiting their ability to benefit from potential price arbitrage.
Thursday night marked a major breakthrough for the rare earths sector, with the US Department of Defence purchasing US$400 million of stock in MP Materials, one of the largest rare earth miners outside of China. The company owns the Mountain Pass mine in California, the only operational rare earth mine in the US.
The news sent local names like Lynas and Iluka Resources up more than 15% on Friday.
The Strategic Context
According to the US Geological Survey, China represented approximately 70% of US rare earth imports in 2023. At the height of US-China trade disputes, China imposed export restrictions on seven rare earth elements essential to the production of advanced technologies, including electric vehicles, fighter jets, and robots.
China's recent export restrictions have severely impacted production across several key industries in Europe and the US. Notable headlines include:
Ford CEO says rare earths shortage forced it to shut factory (NBS)
Tesla's Optimus humanoid robots hit by China's rare earth restrictions, says Musk (CNBC)
Global factory shutdown warnings over China's rare earth ban (AFR)
China's rare-earth mineral squeeze puts defense giants in the crosshairs (CNBC)
MP Materials Stock Surge
Shares in MP Materials surged 50% to levels not seen since the height of rare earth prices in 2022. The unprecedented share price surge reflects several key deal structures:
Pentagon Investment Structure:
The Pentagon purchased a newly created class of preferred shares convertible into common stock and a warrant convertible at $30.03 per share for the next ten years
Exercising the preferred shares and warrant would give the Pentagon approximately 15% ownership of MP Materials
The Pentagon agreed to buy 100% of magnets produced at the company's rare earth magnet manufacturing facility, set to begin production in 2028
Price Guarantee Mechanism: The Pentagon also guaranteed a minimum price of US$110/kg for the next ten years for neodymium-praseodymium oxide (NdPr) that is stockpiled or sold by MP Materials. If the market price falls below US$110/kg, the US will pay MP the difference in quarterly cash payments. If the price of NdPr surpasses US$110, the Pentagon will receive 30% of the upside.
Implications for Rare Earth Stocks
The move highlights the strategic nature of large, operational rare earth projects outside of China. The most significant takeaway is that the US government is willing to pay US$110/kg for NdPr — double the current market rate.
Market Context:
Lynas was selling NdPr at US$53/kg in the March quarter 2025, representing only a modest improvement from the high US$40s that characterized most of FY24
At the height of the rare earths boom, Lynas was selling NdPr for US$145/kg in February 2022
This represents a powerful signal for the broader ex-China industry if the US government maintains this premium over the next ten years
Project Viability: On Friday, Australian Strategic Materials (ASX: ASM) presented results from a Scoping Study evaluating the potential first-phase development of the Dubbo Project, focused on rare earth oxide production. The key finding was that the project breaks even at an NdPr price of US$87/kg, suggesting that higher prices are needed to support more marginal projects.
The Critical Question: Can Others Capture This Premium?
While this development is positive for the industry, the key question remains whether other companies can achieve higher NdPr selling prices.
Lynas' Contractual Constraints: Lynas has a deal with Japan's Sojitz Corp for the supply of up to 7,200 tonnes of NdPr oxide per annum, representing approximately 70% of Lynas' total production capacity. Last month, Macquarie noted that while price differentials are possible in volatile markets through bilateral negotiations, 'it is unlikely to be realised by LYC due to its supply agreement with Sojitz Corporation. More importantly, the product will be sold at market prevailing prices, removing arbitrage opportunities for Lynas.
DoD Connection: However, Lynas does have a multi-year contract with the Department of Defence to build an industrial-scale domestic separation and processing facility for Heavy Rare Earth Elements (HREE). The facility will serve both US and commercial customers, targeted to be operational in FY26, with feedstock sourced from Lynas' Mt Weld deposit and Kalgoorlie facility in Western Australia. While this doesn't guarantee Pentagon investment similar to MP Materials, the company has received millions in funding to progress this facility.
The Bottom Line
The Pentagon's investment in MP Materials represents a watershed moment for the rare earths sector, signaling the US government's willingness to pay significant premiums for supply chain security. While rare earth stocks could potentially overshoot on this news, the ultimate impact will depend on whether other producers can negotiate similar pricing mechanisms or benefit from the broader market repricing this strategic investment may trigger.
