Gold is up 25% year-to-date, so why are ASX gold miners lagging?
Despite gold's 25% surge, most ASX miners lag bullion YTD as analysts resist pricing in elevated levels.
Source: Shutterstock
Mentioned
KEY POINTS
- Only two of 21 ASX gold miners have outperformed bullion year-to-date despite the sector's inherent leverage to gold prices, with the average stock up just 16% versus gold's 25% gain
- Analyst valuations remain anchored to long-term gold price assumptions of ~US$3,000/oz while spot trades at US$5,500/oz, creating a valuation gap where stocks like Newmont and Genesis could see target prices rise 70% at current spot levels
- Gold miners are generating strong free cash flow yields between 8-35% at current prices, positioning them for substantial balance sheet improvements and potential shareholder returns through buybacks and special dividends
Everyone's talking about gold and its parabolic run, with prices soaring 25% year-to-date at a pace that historically takes years, if not decades, to achieve.
Stratospheric gold prices have turned most ASX-listed gold names into cash printers as margins expand and balance sheets begin to build healthy cash and bullion buffers.
The table below shows year-to-date and twelve-month returns for most mid-to-large cap gold miners, with the average stock up 16% year-to-date and 145% over the past twelve months.
Ticker | Company | YTD % | 12M % | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
AMI | Aurelia Metals | 38.8% | 86.1% | $0.34 |
SBM | St Barbara | 35.7% | 223.8% | $0.78 |
ALK | Alkane Resources | 25.9% | 190.8% | $1.68 |
CYL | Catalyst Metals | 22.6% | 152.5% | $9.05 |
EVN | Evolution Mining | 22.4% | 172.6% | $15.39 |
BC8 | Black Cat Syndicate | 22.0% | 116.2% | $1.48 |
NEM | Newmont Corporation | 20.8% | 171.5% | $181.39 |
EMR | Emerald Resources | 20.8% | 92.4% | $7.60 |
WGX | Westgold Resources | 20.2% | 196.9% | $7.58 |
NST | Northern Star Resources | 19.4% | 72.5% | $29.32 |
RMS | Ramelius Resources | 18.2% | 103.8% | $4.84 |
BGL | Bellevue Gold | 16.3% | 64.3% | $1.96 |
GMD | Genesis Minerals | 15.9% | 166.9% | $8.30 |
RSG | Resolute Mining | 15.3% | 228.4% | $1.41 |
CMM | Capricorn Metals | 11.6% | 104.7% | $15.63 |
RRL | Regis Resources | 11.4% | 179.6% | $8.38 |
PRU | Perseus Mining | 10.3% | 115.0% | $6.08 |
VAU | Vault Minerals | 10.1% | 152.1% | $6.00 |
PNR | Pantoro Gold | 8.0% | 182.4% | $5.29 |
OBM | Ora Banda Mining | -8.2% | 73.5% | $1.41 |
MEK | Meeka Metals | -11.1% | 118.2% | $0.24 |
Source: Market Index | Data as at Friday, 30 January 2026 open
While all but four stocks have outperformed gold over the past twelve months, only two gold names are tracking ahead of bullion year-to-date.
That doesn't add up when you consider that gold miners represent a leveraged play on the metal. If a gold miner has an all-in sustaining cost of US$1,500/oz and gold prices jump from US$4,500 to US$5,500 (a 22% increase), that delivers a 33% lift in profit margin. The operating leverage is very, very substantial. Yet gold miners seem reluctant to move higher.
Reluctance to price in higher gold prices
One of the main reasons gold miners aren't trading higher is this disbelief that current prices will hold.
Most long-term analyst forecasts remain far below current spot prices. Macquarie, for example, assumes a long-term gold price of US$3,000/oz as of 19 January, though the broker acknowledges that net asset values and target prices would more than double at current spot levels.
This gap between long-term and spot assumptions produces vastly different valuations. Here are some examples from the Macquarie report:
Newmont (Outperform) with $175.00 target at long-run vs. $297.00 target at spot
Evolution (Underperform) with $10.10 target at long-run vs. $18.50 target at spot
Genesis Minerals (Outperform) $8.40 target at long-run vs. $14.95 target at spot
From a modeling perspective, this translates to assuming high gold prices for the current year, more modest forecasts over the next few years, then a reversion to US$3,000/oz in outer years.
Other factors to consider
Several other factors may be weighing on the sector, though they shouldn't result in such broad underperformance relative to gold.
Poor operational results: Mining is hard and plenty of names have dipped in recent weeks following weaker-than-expected quarterly results. Ora Banda shares fell more than 10% on Thursday after hiking its AISC to A$3,250-3,350/oz versus prior guidance of A$2,800-2,900/oz (a 16% increase at the midpoint) due to higher tonnages processed via third-party milling. Other names that sold off on poor results include Pantoro, Northern Star and Regis Resources.
Royalties: Governments want a piece of the pie, and some are strong-arming their way to higher royalties. Perseus Mining flagged a higher AISC for both the December quarter and FY26 as Côte d'Ivoire hiked royalties by a further 2%.
Sovereign risk: West African Resources is widely forecast to generate more than 30% free cash flow in FY26. However, the stock isn't trading higher because the company remains in discussions with the Burkina Faso government following their request for additional equity interest in Kiaka.
Hedging: Few hedged players remain, with names like Capricorn Metals becoming fully unhedged in late 2025 and Bellevue Gold making voluntary hedge book pre-deliveries. Perseus stands out with 175,000 ounces hedged (11% of three-year forecast production) at US$3,692/oz.
Where to from here?
The vertical gold price move undoubtedly gives an unsettling feeling, and such bubble-like rallies don't tend to end well. But regardless of what the future holds, current conditions will likely drive material earnings outcomes for most gold miners. Evolution Mining, for example, has seen its gearing improve to 6% in the December 2025 quarter compared to 11% in the September 2025 quarter and 31% two years ago.
Macquarie's modeling shows a massive uplift in free cash flow yield for gold miners at spot prices, with Newmont, Northern Star and Evolution all sitting around 8-9%. Genesis is forecast to generate 10.4% while Regis Resources and West African Resources show outsized numbers at 20.0% and 34.9% respectively. Such free cash flow outcomes should translate to substantial balance sheet deleveraging where applicable and possible shareholder returns through buybacks and special dividends.
The bottom line is that gold miners are relatively cheap, provided gold prices stay put or continue trending higher. Even if prices fall to US$5,000, that's still a net positive for the sector.
